
To counteract the poison of Hollywood’s long-standing, lazy and frankly despicable habit of painting Muslims as the bad guys, Mahershala Ali provides a heartfelt and believable antidote in this engrossing if preposterous mixture of action thriller and family drama.
Ali plays Latif, a hitman whose ruthless expertise with a deadly weapon is balanced with his responsibilities as a newly single father following the death of his wife, but this is clearly no True Lies-style knockabout comedy. It mines the unexpected clashing of the personal with the professional not for giggles, but for insights into the humanity of someone whose job is to be inhuman.
The camera stays close to the action, whether it’s a bone-crunching fight scene or the solemn ritual of saying goodbye to the recently deceased. Details are vital, be they faces or swords, this dedicated focus suggesting the universal theme of death being another part of life, regardless of who’s dealing it out – God or Man.
Just as universal are the domestic problems faced by the family (running out of baby milk, arranging last-minute childcare, eruptions of teenage rebellion), a gentle but persistent reminder that when it comes down to it, we’re all the same underneath our creeds, colours and clothes.
Still, the film dutifully depicts a community whose quotidian practices are treated as arcane and dangerous mysteries by much of mainstream Western culture. That alone makes it a bold and worthwhile enterprise, but because Latif’s holy missions originate from his imam (a generously bearded Giancarlo Esposito) a sharper point is made about what it takes to defend one’s people.
By using shallow focus and lighting from the back and sides, cinematographer Katelin Arizmendi lends the story a certain studied realism, while also helping to keep the machinations of the plot under wraps for as long as possible. When the action does burst into life, post-rock band Son Lux drenches it in showers of synthesised shrieking with a decidedly Eastern flavour.
Bassam Tariq directs his authentically terse script with both élan and precision, allowing moments of dark humour to leaven what might otherwise have been too dry and serious for its own good. He airs all of the characters’ grievances and lets us be the jury, right up until an ending that pushes the magic-realist envelope a little too far for the infidels.
The duality of the central character – hero to his community, villain to anyone who threatens it – resonates around the wider story, emerging in the conflict between the requirements of the minority of which he is a part, and the omnipresent peer pressure of modern America. The script is full of little ironies that can’t wait to ‘what about’ him into submission.
At mosque his daughter wears a sports jersey as well as a hijab, and gets caught hanging out in an ultraviolet party limo; vape smoke surrounds Latif himself like a wraith whispering in his ear about the more liberal life he could have had. It’s a war of attrition between two cultures, and the film is unable (or more likely unwilling) to resolve it.
Even when they’re not hidden behind his badass superhero outfit, Mahershala Ali’s stony features give little away as he terminates his quarry with consummate skill. But when he cracks into a smile of fatherly dotage he becomes the kind of fearless protector all our inner children would cling to for dear life, and that rich, deep voice is a vessel for surprising quantities of humanising desperation.
A lot of emotional storytelling is demanded of him, and he responds with his customary intensity, subtlety and dynamism. He swerves from harried father to avenging angel with the grace of a ballet dancer, and we’re inclined to buy what he’s selling no matter how absurd the circumstances.
John Cho’s fundamentalist Christian antagonist, a MAGA-coded gun-totin’ cowboy who’s apparently forgotten at least two of the Ten Commandments, is drawn with broad strokes. But in this day and age, such a figure seems less satire than documentary; and besides, Cho plays it with enough restrained menace that we look forward to seeing him taken down a peg or two. Caught in the middle by his own idiotic design, Abubakr Ali has a memorably sleazy role as the wannabe pimp and pornographer who’s turned his back on his faith and has the hilarious temerity to think he’s a match for either of them.
As its repetitive title insists, Your Mother Your Mother Your Mother is ultimately more interested in the drama side of its unusual equation than the action side, using the estimable talents of its star to explore the perhaps impossible contradictions of being a Muslim in America. But by making a radical case for unity over division in such spectacular terms, it has a better chance of being heard.
-Stew Mott-


